Article

Overtrading: Warning Signs, Hidden Costs and How to Stop It

Overtrading means trading more often, or with bigger positions, than your trading plan allows, and the habit drains an account through extra costs and weaker trades. Overtrading has no fixed trade count, which is why many traders miss the habit until losses and costs pile up.

Key Takeaways

  • Overtrading means taking more or larger trades than your trading plan justifies, so no single trade count marks the line for every trader.
  • Every extra trade pays the spread and any commission, so 10 trades a day at a $5 illustration cost add up to $1,050 a month.
  • A trading journal check over your last 30 trades shows overtrading when the C trades, taken with no setup, lose money on average.
  • Rules set before the session cut overtrading, and the main ones are a daily trade limit, a daily loss limit and a cooldown break.

What Is Overtrading?

Overtrading is taking more trades, or larger trades, than your trading plan justifies, usually driven by emotion with no valid setup behind each trade. Excessive trading is another name for the same habit.

Overtrading has no fixed trade count. Overtrading is measured against your own trading plan and trading style, so 15 trades a day can be normal for one trader and far too many for another.

Overtrading takes two main forms.

  • Frequency overtrading means placing more trades than your trading plan's setups produce, often small and fast trades taken to stay busy.
  • Size overtrading means opening positions larger than your risk rules allow, often to win back a loss in a single trade.

The word has two other uses. Broker churning is when a broker trades a client's account too often to earn commissions. Business overtrading is when a company grows faster than its cash, which the FAQs cover. Overtrading by traders shows up in a few recognizable patterns.

Types of Overtrading

Overtrading comes in five common types the trader controls, plus broker churning, where a broker overtrades a client's account. Finding your own type in the table shows which rule your trading plan is missing.

TypeWhat It Looks LikeUsual Trigger
Frequency overtradingMany trades, often small and fastBoredom, screen always open
Size overtradingPositions larger than your risk rules allowTrying to win back a loss quickly
Discretionary overtradingChanging size and rules on gut feelNo fixed rules for size
Technical overtradingPicking indicators to justify a trade already decidedConfirmation bias
Shotgun overtradingMany small unplanned positions open at onceWanting action
Broker churningA broker trades a client account too oftenEarning commissions

Undertrading is the opposite problem, where a trader skips valid setups out of fear after a loss. Every type of overtrading the trader controls has the same root, an emotion or a missing rule, and that root is where the causes start.

What Causes Overtrading?

Overtrading is mostly caused by emotional decisions combined with a trading plan that is missing or ignored. Overtrading psychology explains how emotions such as fear, greed, boredom and overconfidence can push traders to take unnecessary trades or increase position sizes beyond their risk limits.

  • Trying to win back a loss leads to revenge trading, which is one cause of overtrading where trade count and size rise straight after a losing trade.
  • FOMO, meaning fear of missing out, pulls traders into moves that are already running, and the fear of ending the day with a loss adds late trades.
  • Overconfidence after a winning streak leads traders into weaker setups and bigger sizes, because recent wins feel like proof of skill.
  • Boredom and the urge to stay busy turn a quiet market into a reason to trade, even when no setup has formed.
  • No written trading plan leaves every decision to mood, so no rule says when a trade is not allowed.
  • Trading platforms that feel like a game add to the urge, because notifications and one tap orders make each new trade fast and easy.
  • Dropping to shorter timeframes shows more signals per hour, and more signals look like more reasons to trade.

Overtrading often runs in a loop because a loss creates the urge to win the money back, the urge brings more or bigger trades, and those trades bring higher costs and more losses, which start the loop again.

Overtrading cycle diagram showing a loop of four steps: loss, urge to win it back, more or bigger trades, then higher costs and losses

Causes are hard to see in the moment, so the signs that show up in your own trading are the easier place to start.

Signs You Are Overtrading

The clearest sign of overtrading is a trade count that rises while the reason behind each trade gets weaker. Watch for these warning signs in your own trading.

  • Trading more often than your trading plan allows is the most direct sign.
  • Entering a trade without being able to name the setup shows the trade came from an urge instead of a rule.
  • Placing more trades straight after a loss points to revenge trading.
  • Trading outside your set hours, such as late at night, means the session never really ends.
  • Position sizes creeping up over a week or a month signal size overtrading.
  • Moving or removing your stop loss to keep a losing trade open breaks the exit rule in your trading plan.
  • Dropping to a lower timeframe to find something to trade means the chart is supplying excuses instead of setups.
  • Watching charts all day and feeling anxious with no open trade shows trading has become a habit you cannot switch off.
  • Trading costs taking a bigger share of your profits is a money sign of too many trades.
  • Skipping your trading journal because there are too many trades to log removes the record that would show the problem.

Checklist of 10 signs of overtrading, including more trades than planned, trading after a loss, moving stops and skipping the trading journal

Warning signs stay a feeling until a record confirms them, and a trading journal check gives that record.

How to Check Your Trading Journal for Overtrading

You can tell if you are overtrading by tagging your last 30 or more trades in your trading journal and comparing the results of each group.

  1. Tag each trade A for a full setup from your trading plan, B for a partial setup, or C for a trade with no setup.
  2. Note how many trades you took on the day of each trade.
  3. Compare the average result of A, B and C trades, then compare your light days with your busy days.

If C trades lose money on average, or your busiest days are your worst days, you are overtrading. The group that loses money points to the rule you need to add.

TagMeaningWhat to Do If This Group Loses on Average
AFull setup from your trading planReview the plan itself, not your trade count
BPartial setup, some rules missingTighten the checklist so B trades are skipped
CNo setup, taken from boredom, FOMO or after a lossBan C trades and add a daily trade limit or cooldown break

Once the extra trades are visible in your trading journal, the next question is what those trades cost you.

Why Is Overtrading Bad for Traders?

Overtrading is bad for traders because it raises trading costs, lowers the quality of each trade, makes deep losses more likely and wears the trader out. ESMA, the EU markets regulator, found in 2018 that between 74% and 89% of retail CFD accounts lose money, so most traders have little room for extra costs or weak trades.

How Overtrading Costs Add Up

Every trade pays the spread and any commission whether the trade wins or loses, so trading costs rise in a straight line with trade count while your edge does not. The spread is the gap between the buy and sell price, and a commission is a fee some accounts charge per trade. Your edge is the average profit your strategy makes per trade over many trades. Positions held overnight also pay swap, an overnight financing charge.

The monthly cost table uses a round cost of $5 per trade and 21 trading days a month. The numbers are an illustration only, because real costs depend on the instrument, account type and market.

Trades per DayCost per Trade (Illustration)Trading DaysMonthly Cost
1$521$105
5$521$525
10$521$1,050
20$521$2,100

Bar chart of monthly trading costs at $5 per trade over 21 days: $105 for 1 trade a day, $525 for 5, $1,050 for 10 and $2,100 for 20

A trade with little or no edge loses money once costs are paid. In the illustration, the planned A setup still makes money after costs, the weak B setup breaks even and the boredom C trade loses.

Trade TypeExpected Result Before CostsCostExpected Result After Costs
Planned A setup+$25$5+$20
Weak B setup+$5$5$0
Boredom C trade$0$5−$5

Research on stock investors points the same way. Brad Barber and Terrance Odean studied 66,465 US households from 1991 to 1996 in The Journal of Finance in 2000. The households that traded most earned 11.4% a year after costs while the market returned 17.9%, and the authors linked the gap to trading costs and trade frequency.

Trading costs are the visible loss from overtrading. The bigger loss usually comes from the trades themselves.

Lower Quality Trades and Bigger Losses

Overtrading lowers the quality of each trade, because every extra trade is usually a weaker setup taken with less care, so the average result per trade falls. Larger or repeated trades after a loss deepen the drawdown, which is the fall from an account's peak to its lowest point. With leverage, several open positions use more margin and can push margin level down toward a margin call, a broker warning that the account is running short of margin.

Overtrading also wears down the trader behind the account.

Stress and Burnout From Overtrading

Overtrading causes stress and burnout, because long hours of screen time and constant decisions lead to decision fatigue, where each new choice gets less focus. Tired traders make worse trades, and worse trades bring more losses and more stress. If trading starts to feel compulsive or hard to stop, speaking to a qualified professional is a sensible step.

Stress from overtrading raises the obvious question of where active trading ends and overtrading begins.

How Many Trades a Day Is Overtrading?

No single number of trades a day counts as overtrading. Any trade beyond what your tested strategy produces is overtrading, so the limit depends on your trading plan and trading style. The ranges in the table are commonly quoted examples from traders, not rules.

Trading StyleCommonly Quoted RangeWhen It Becomes Overtrading
Scalping10 or more trades a dayTrades outside the plan's setups or hours, or costs eating most of the profit
Day tradingAbout 1 to 5 trades a dayAdding trades after losses or when nothing matches the plan
Swing tradingA few trades a weekTaking daily trades from lower timeframe charts

The practical way to set your own number is to check your trading journal for your average number of valid A setups per day. If your trading plan produces two A setups on an average day, a third or fourth trade needs a clear reason. Scalpers can take many trades a day without overtrading, as long as each trade matches the plan.

Knowing your limit is the first step, and fixed rules turn that limit into a habit.

How to Stop Overtrading

You stop overtrading by setting your rules before the session starts and treating those rules as fixed, so fewer and better trades replace many weak ones. Each of the seven steps adds one rule, and each rule reduces risk without removing it.

Step 1: Write a Trading Plan With Clear Entry Rules

Write a trading plan that lists which markets you trade, which timeframe you use and exactly what a valid setup looks like. Include where the stop loss goes and where the profit target sits for each setup. If a trade does not match the trading plan, you do not take the trade. Review the trading plan against your trading journal every week.

Step 2: Use a Pre Trade Checklist

Use a short pre trade checklist before every order, and skip the trade if any answer is no.

  • Does this trade match my setup?
  • Is my stop loss set?
  • Is my position size within my rule?
  • Am I under my daily trade limit?

Step 3: Set a Daily Trade Limit

Set a daily trade limit based on your trading journal's average number of valid A setups per day, and close the platform once you reach it. A daily trade limit can make you miss a good setup now and then. Missing one good trade usually costs far less than taking ten forced ones, so the daily trade limit is worth that trade off.

Step 4: Set a Daily Loss Limit

Set a daily loss limit, the most you will lose in one day, as a small share of your account decided before the session. Once you hit the daily loss limit, the trading day is over, whatever the chart does next. A daily loss limit caps a bad day, but a price gap that skips your stop loss can still push the loss past it.

Step 5: Fix Your Position Size Before You Trade

Fix your position size with a set rule before you trade, such as the 1 to 2% rule, so size never grows to chase a loss. The 1 to 2% rule means risking a small share of the account on each trade, and the 1 to 2% rule is a common guideline, not a guarantee. TMGM's position size calculator can help you work out the size for each trade.

Step 6: Trade Only in Set Hours

Trade only in set hours that match when your strategy works best, and stay off the platform outside those hours. Set hours cut the late night and lunch break trades that come from boredom. If you keep overtrading on short charts, moving up to a higher timeframe gives fewer signals and more time to think.

Step 7: Take a Cooldown Break After a Loss or a Big Win

Take a cooldown break for a set time after a loss, two losses in a row or a big win, before you place the next trade. A cooldown break lets the urge to win money back, or the rush after a win, fade before the next decision. Turn off non essential price alerts during the cooldown break as well.

Frequently Asked Questions About Overtrading

Is Overtrading Illegal?

No, overtrading your own account is not illegal, and the harm falls only on your own account. Broker churning is different. Broker churning is when a broker trades a client's account too often to earn commissions, and financial regulators in many markets treat broker churning as misconduct.

Is Scalping the Same as Overtrading?

No, scalping is not the same as overtrading. Scalping is a planned strategy that takes many small trades by design, and each scalping trade follows set rules. Scalping becomes overtrading when the scalper trades outside the plan's setups or hours, adds trades after losses, or ignores how spreads and commissions eat into small profits.

What Is the Difference Between Overtrading and Revenge Trading?

Overtrading is taking more or larger trades than your trading plan justifies, while revenge trading is one cause of overtrading that starts after a loss. Revenge trading means trying to win the money back fast with more or bigger trades. Overtrading is wider and can also come from boredom, FOMO or overconfidence.

ComparisonOvertradingRevenge Trading
What it isMore or larger trades than the plan justifiesTrading to win back a loss quickly
TriggerLosses, boredom, FOMO, overconfidenceA recent loss
Typical behaviorMany trades, weaker setupsBigger size, broken rules, removed stop loss
Main fixDaily trade limit and trading planDaily loss limit and cooldown break

Can You Overtrade After a Winning Streak?

Yes, you can overtrade after a winning streak. A run of wins builds overconfidence, which can push a trader into weaker setups or bigger position sizes than the trading plan allows. A cooldown break after a big win gives that confidence time to settle before the next trade.

What Is Overtrading in Business?

In business, overtrading means a company grows sales faster than its cash and working capital can support. The company runs short of cash to pay suppliers and staff even while sales look strong. This guide covers overtrading in trading, where the term means taking more or larger trades than a trading plan justifies.

A group of expert analyst with strengths in fundamental and technical analysis, and years of experience in the Global Equity Markets, Forex, Precious Metals, Oils and other commodities, as well as Crypto, and so on.
Join Over 1,000,000 clients on our award-winning trading platform
1
Apply for a Live
Account
2
Fund Your
Account
3
Start Trading
Instantly
Open Account