Senate scrutinises Trump's SEC nominees over tokenisation and crypto oversight

  • Crypto regulation and financial oversight came under scrutiny on Thursday as the Senate Banking Committee questioned President Trump's SEC nominees.
  • Tokenisation rules, regulatory exemptions and prediction markets drew senators' concerns, alongside the SEC's supervision of emerging financial products.
  • With Democrats preparing to assume control of Congress in January, the hearing comes after Trump's CFTC nominees were questioned on Tuesday.

Digital asset regulation, tokenisation and prediction markets were in focus at Thursday's hearing, where senators questioned President Donald Trump's nominees to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on the agency's regulatory approach.

TMGM Analysis: Financial Market News, Economic Calendar & Market Insights

How would Trump's SEC nominees approach crypto regulation?

On a range of issues affecting crypto markets, the Senate Banking Committee quizzed Republican nominee Steven Levine and Democratic nominee Kristin Johnson. Questions covered the SEC's policy on tokenisation, its reliance on regulatory exemptions and its authority over emerging financial products.

Rather than relying on the existing innovation exemption, the SEC should put its tokenisation policy through formal rulemaking, Johnson suggested. A public comment process, she argued, would give market participants an opportunity to voice concerns about the approach.

Responding to objections from companies affected by the policy, she said she would welcome a chance to review the issue through formal rulemaking.

Describing the SEC's recent exemption as narrowly defined and time-bound, Levine defended the measure. He argued that financial innovations such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs) had initially operated under exemptive orders before formal rules were eventually introduced.

Prediction markets and the SEC's authority over products including single-stock perpetual futures were also put to the nominees. Could some of these products qualify as security-based swaps, Democratic Senator Catherine Cortez Masto asked. Johnson said significant questions about the commission's authority remained unresolved.

Enforcement, financial stability and the SEC's independence also featured in lawmakers' questions. While Levine said the agency should continue actively enforcing securities laws, Johnson recognised that private markets could pose systemic risks.

How would CFTC nominees oversee prediction markets?

Before Thursday's hearing, Trump's CFTC nominees, Matthew Rowland and Nathan Anonick, appeared at Tuesday's Senate Agriculture Committee session. Prediction markets and sports-related event contracts were the main focus of that discussion.

Concerns from states and tribal authorities about the CFTC's stance on prediction markets drew a sympathetic response from Rowland; Anonick, meanwhile, characterised the issue as legally complex. Senators also asked both nominees about staffing cuts at the CFTC and whether its resources were adequate for its growing responsibilities.

Asked about President Trump's family links to prediction market businesses, both nominees said the law should apply equally to all and enforcement should be impartial.

Democrats' midterm election victories gave them control of both chambers of Congress, providing the backdrop to the hearings. Senate leadership is consequently set to change when the new Congress convenes in January.

Scrutiny by Democrats of Trump's crypto-related business interests and family connections has intensified. The concerns they raised also made efforts to move the Clarity Act forward more difficult.

Without the required 60 votes to invoke cloture, the legislation failed to progress in the Senate: 49 lawmakers voted in favour and 50 against. Among the objections cited by Democrats were ethics concerns linked to Trump's crypto interests.

A 49–50 vote left the bill short of the 60 votes required to end debate, halting its progress in the Senate. Explaining their opposition, Democrats cited ethical concerns surrounding President Donald Trump's cryptocurrency connections as one of their reasons.